HP “Touch” is neither “Personal” nor helpful
HP (Hewlett-Packard) is touting its latest notion of bringing a new face to personal computing in the form of TouchSmart PCs. They suggest you should “Let one into your life today and get a feel for what it can do.” Prior to the TouchSmart campaign, is was all about HP’s “The Computer is Personal Again.”
Well, I have had HP – and Compaq – PCs in my home and business for years; one could say I may even fall into the loyal customer category with add-ons from HP like scanners and internal drives (including the lightScribe DVD drive). Until recently, I was considering one of their new Mini-Note PCs.
It never ceases to amaze me how one bad customer service experience can sour an otherwise loyal customer; in this case, it was me. Recovering from a wealth of BSOD errors on a HP laptop, I was down to non-functioning USB ports on the HP xb2000 Expansion Base. Up until this time, the expansion base – works like a docking station – was an integral part of this computing environment.
Wireless keyboard and mouse, along with plenty of ports in all shapes, size, and purpose, the expansion base was an excellent landing zone for the laptop. One detachable power and utility connector - from the expansion base to the laptop - would bring everything to life. And, the tilt feature would put the laptop screen at just the right eye level for ease of use and comfort.
I was determined to get it back into service. So much so, I spent countless hours of troubleshooting, reloading drivers, adjusting configurations, and the list goes on. Some of it was with the help of HP’s online chat support, but most of it was on my own (with the help of the Web and various forums). In the end, it was declared to be a “hardware issue” with the expansion base.
Finally succumbing to the bad news, I decided to pursue repair or replacement options. With HP, this had always worked well in the past and I had no reason to believe it wouldn’t work this time. What a waste of time; I can sum it up like this. I spent over 40 minutes in a never-ending loop with the HP Parts Store, each person saying I was being transferred to tech support or customer service. Finally breaking the loop, and 20 additional minutes later, I was informed this unit is “obsolete” and there were no repair options or parts available.
Unwilling to accept this outcome – I am a tenacious spirit in that regard – I sent a letter to a manager within HP’s Personal Systems Group – Americas. Giving it ample time for some level of response – in the letter I encouraged the recipient to delegate it to someone else – I ended up sending another copy by email after calling the manager’s office. Even after talking to someone, the issue has gone without a response.
What to do? I could part with some money and buy the newer HP Expansion Base xb3000. Well, that presents another issue. According to the HP Store, it’s no longer available from HP (but, it is available on the open market), and its replacement, the xb4, doesn’t work with my model of notebook. Now that’s what I call a short product cycle in the channel – it wasn’t that long ago I saw an xb3000 product review at CNET.com.
Enter the state of nothingness. I’m out of options for what will soon become either a very large paperweight, or food for the Think Green recycling program of computer gear. What’s been you experience? How far will you pursue resolution when it comes to something like my expansion base example?
Pondering this for a moment, how much computer gear ends up without resolution in the hands of individuals and companies? Looking back on companies I have worked for, I can remember closets and storage cabinets full of ‘out of service’ gear. With today’s economic conditions, are you more or less likely to pursue fixing older gear?


